Published on: October 29, 2026 at 9:09 am
Leading up to the 2026 US midterm elections, many voters have told journalists that they voted for President Donald Trump but are changing allegiances to vote for Democrats. Some researchers have argued that followers of a powerful political leader like Trump have psychological vulnerabilities—including a deep-seated need for security, a fear of isolation, and a craving for certainty during times of crisis—that drive them to embrace charismatic but harmful figures such as overbearing supervisors and toxic leaders.
Academy of Management Scholar Jeffrey Pfeffer of Stanford University said Academy of Management Member Jean Lipman-Blumen of Claremont Graduate University wrote a still-relevant book in 2006 called The Allure of Toxic Leaders: Why We Follow Destructive Bosses and Corrupt Politicians—and How We Can Survive Them, which examines why individuals repeatedly surrender autonomy to destructive bosses and corrupt politicians.
“We need to understand why people will follow and put up with leaders who are not really interested in the well-being of the people who are following them, which is a kind of a paradox if you think about it,” Pfeffer said. “It’s an ironic fact that Donald Trump was elected twice: The first time he did lose the popular vote but won the Electoral College; the second time he lost; and the third time he ran, he won the popular vote.
“But what is ironic is that he ran on a platform of lowering prices for the average people, which was arguably the number-one campaign issue, because people were so concerned about the cost of living and they felt that neither party was really listening to them,” he said. “Donald Trump used that as a talking point, which was very effective on the campaign trail, and among the other things that he mentioned often was not getting into any new wars.
“He was even critical of former President George W. Bush for getting into the Iraq War, calling the 2003 invasion of Iraq ‘a big, fat mistake’ and potentially ‘the worst single mistake ever made in the history of our country.’ He also criticized Obama and others for different wars in Iraq and Afghanistan and for continuing those conflicts and the immense waste of resources, the loss of thousands of American lives and trillions of dollars spent on the conflicts. So, a lot of people thought it was ironic that he was now involved in foreign conflicts of his own making.”
Campaign promises not kept
“He started the Iran war and then not only failed follow through on his campaign promise to bring prices down but also caused the oil and gas prices to rise again, worsening inflation,” Pfeffer said. “And by the way, he put in tariffs, which have raised prices for everything—it’s an inflationary policy.
“The oil and gas industry, of course, permeates the coverage, because almost everything you buy is delivered, and it’s delivered in a truck that uses diesel fuel, which is quite expensive due to the Iran war,” he said. “But more than that, he’s put in the tariffs, which have raised prices on all kinds of stuff and worsened the cost-of-living crisis.”
A sample of Pfeffer’s AOM research findings: