Skip to main content

Academy of Management Today

By Daniel Butcher

US Secretary of War (FKA Defense) Pete Hegseth is facing intensifying bipartisan backlash, public disapproval, and calls for his resignation over a controversial tenure marked by military purges based on race, gender, sexual orientation, and perceived loyalty to himself and President Trump. Critics from both political parties—including high-profile Republican lawmakers—have condemned Hegseth for creating a climate of fear by stripping the military of experienced four-star generals and other high-ranking officers, as well as prioritizing polarizing cultural warfare over combat readiness. Opponents argue his aggressive management style and haphazard handling of the Iran war have undermined the US’s national security, fueling widespread demands from members of Congress and others for his immediate removal to avoid a looming impeachment battle.

According to Academy of Management Scholar Jeffrey Pfeffer of Stanford University, Hegseth has modeled terrible leadership behavior during his tenure.

“Look at who he’s passed over for promotion in the military, who he’s promoted, and the way he talks about that, and if anyone happens to be female or African American and a four- or five-star general, well, that was DEI,” Pfeffer said. “But if there’s a three- or four-star general who supports Trump and is male and not African American, he’ll get promoted above the more experienced, more qualified, more decorated female or African American general.

“The statistics on what has happened to the promotion of white males and the demotion of women and African Americans in the in the current regime couldn’t be clearer, and so Trump and Hegseth have licensed, in some sense, the worst bigotry and the worst forms of behavior,” he said.

On October 28, Hegseth fired Army Lt. Gen. Brett Sylvia, the Pentagon’s top military planner, the second general to be dismissed from that post known as the J5. Dozens of senior military leaders have resigned, retired (or been forced to retire), or been fired since Hegseth became Secretary of Defense.

Hegseth has adopted Trump’s combative, polarizing political style of public speaking, abandoning the traditionally apolitical rhetoric of previous Pentagon leaders. In official addresses, Hegseth has mirrored Trump’s frequent use of vulgar language to enforce policy, including at a speech in Quantico, where he boasted about mandatory testosterone testing for members of the military and demanded an elite fighting force with “no wimps or radicals.” Critics and legal experts warn that Hegseth’s ideological framing of the military as a culture-war battleground—combined with his mockery of institutional critics, women, people of color, and LGBTQ+ members of the military—has weaponized official military directives.

“Hegseth’s and Trump’s language is horrible in terms of—again—licensing racism, sexism, homophobia, and transphobia and basically making fun of people with physical disabilities, and so, fundamentally, the effects of Donald Trump will far outlast the Trump presidency, and it will pervade our society probably well beyond the domain of politics,” Pfeffer said.

“We all know that he is a very poor role model for leadership, which, by the way something that [Academy of Management Scholar] Jeffrey Sonnenfeld wrote about way back in 2004, when he was asked to write a column in The Wall Street Journal entitled ‘The Last Emperor’ about Trump’s television program The Apprentice. He said, ‘This is a horrible way to lead,’ basically turning people against each other, etc. etc.

“But Sonnenfeld’s point that ‘this is a bad example for a leader to set’ is even more true today, and bad examples tend to send a message to other people about how they can act or ought to behave.”

 

A sample of Pfeffer’s AOM research findings:

Author

  • Dan Butcher

    Daniel Butcher is a writer and the Managing Editor of AOM Today at the Academy of Management (AOM). Previously, he was a writer and the Finance Editor for Strategic Finance magazine and Management Accounting Quarterly, a scholarly journal, at the Institute of Management Accountants (IMA). Prior to that, he worked as a writer/editor at The Financial Times, including daily FT sister publications Ignites and FundFire, as well as Crain Communications’s InvestmentNews and Crain’s Wealth, eFinancialCareers, and Arizent’s Financial Planning, Re:Invent|Wealth, On Wall Street, Bank Investment Consultant, and Money Management Executive. He earned his bachelor’s degree, Cum Laude, from the University of Colorado Boulder and his master’s degree from New York University. You can reach him at [email protected] or via LinkedIn.

    View all posts
Click here for sharing