Skip to main content

Academy of Management Today

By Aparna Joshi

When large firms lack a succession plan, the consequences for stakeholders can be immense. Case in point: Nvidia. On November 12, CEO Jensen Huang resigned amid mounting scrutiny over personal scandals, with implications for proprietary company secrets and national security, leaving investors and policymakers asking a question that the company apparently cannot yet answer: Who comes next? Huang, who ran Nvidia with roughly 60 direct reports and no designated successor, is currently replaced by CFO Colette Kress as interim CEO. Because Nvidia is worth more than $4 trillion and is a central player in the global AI supply chain, this unplanned transition has implications for cloud providers, chipmakers, governments, and pension funds.

Unfortunately, this is not an uncommon event. Indeed, a growing number of CEO departures end with an interim CEO in the job, suggesting that these companies did not have a succession plan in place.

In a study conducted with fellow Academy of Management scholars Donald Hambrick and Jiyeon Kang, published in the Academy of Management Review, we argue that a company’s succession readiness is shaped years in advance by the incumbent CEO’s “generativity mindset.” This mindset has two dimensions:

1) How committed is the CEO to developing future leaders?

2) How much does the CEO need to control the succession process?

Based on these two dimensions, we identify four archetypes of CEO generativity:

  • Generative CEOs who develop several strong executives and let the board choose among them.
  • Hyper-generative CEOs who groom a single hand-picked heir. Although the handoff is smooth, the successor is often a clone of the predecessor, which can be a liability in dynamic environments.
  • Hypo-generative CEOs are low on both dimensions: neither committed to developing the next generation nor interested in controlling the process.
  • Anti-generative CEOs see themselves as irreplaceable, sometimes even thwarting capable executives from gaining the experience they would need to step up.

The last two archetypes are the most likely to produce what scholars term “crisis successions.” In the absence of a plan, the board must choose quickly between an untested insider or an unfamiliar outsider, which is costly for shareholders and concerning for other stakeholders.

Selecting CEOs for their generativity is one solution. More importantly, we want to highlight the central role played by boards. Our work suggests that a truly committed board can push even reluctant CEOs to build bench strength by mentoring and evaluating potential successors. In practice, that means asking every year for the names of executives who could take over, giving those executives broad, company-wide responsibilities, and treating a founder’s brilliance as a reason for more planning, not less.

Even the most talented CEOs have an expiry date. The question for organizations’ leaders and board members is whether they will plan ahead or wait for the inevitable and take on far greater risk.

Flat structure by design or by default?

Huang famously ran Nvidia with a flat hierarchy—managing dozens of direct reports with no clear second-in-command—and once joked that he planned to stay for another 30 or 40 years. People have asked me, “Does that look like a leader who was simply too focused on running the business to groom a successor, or someone who structured the company to ensure no rival could ever emerge?”

Both of these themes can be true. Although the Nvidia structure seems unusual, many CEOs see themselves as indispensable to the company and feel that no one can step into their shoes. As such, developing a new generation of leaders may simply not be on their radar.

Nvidia’s startup culture may also help explain its approach to structuring reporting relationships. As a founder and the CEO, Huang possibly saw himself as indispensable, and the board seemed to be aligned with his view. Ironically, given how high the stakes were, this is the type of situation that actually required a “generative” CEO. Such a CEO would have comprehensively assessed multiple senior executives for their advancement potential, provided them with multiple opportunities to demonstrate their leadership potential, and set in motion a “horse race” succession, in which multiple contenders are encouraged by the board to compete for the position.

The danger of “indispensable” founders

According to our research, “Indispensable” founders may come close to the “anti-generative” archetype. Such CEOs reject, consciously or subconsciously, the central premise of generativity—that others must eventually replace them. They cannot fathom their departure, and they especially cannot fathom that someone else could suitably fill their shoes. As such, they cling to their positions as long as possible by seeing to it that viable internal replacements are simply not available.

Elon Musk and other Silicon Valley CEOs have rallied behind Huang and publicly said—or tweeted—that he is irreplaceable and should be reinstated. Unfortunately, when the cult of personality is at play, the incidence of such crisis succession situations may increase, with shareholders and investors ultimately bearing the risk.

Why boards hesitate to push back on founders

Fewer than 35% of Fortune 500 boards regularly put CEO succession on their meeting agendas.

Unfortunately, boards might disengage for various reasons. Some boards may be reluctant to initiate succession planning, especially before the CEO’s departure is imminent, out of concern for affronting or alarming the CEO. Moreover, succession may seem a distant eventuality, out on the horizon, compared to other, more pressing board matters, and thus is easily postponed.

Relatedly, in light of today’s fluid executive labor market, which allows executives to readily move from firm to firm, boards may be skeptical about the basic value of investing in cultivating their companies’ future leaders.

 

Author

  • Aparna Joshi of the University of Michigan’s Ross School of Business

    Academy of Management Scholar Aparna Joshi of the University of Michigan’s Ross School of Business is an award-winning organizational scholar who studies the science of how human beings relate to one another across differences. Over the past 20 years, Joshi’s research has focused on leadership, gender, and equity among scientists, lawyers, engineers and chief executives. Her research aims to build actionable theoretical models that can inform practices aimed at reducing barriers and enhancing inclusion in these settings.  

    Joshi’s research appears in the leading journals in the field of management and organizations, including *Academy of Management Journal* and *Academy of Management Review*. In 2014, she received the Cummings Award for Early to Mid-Career Scholarly Achievement, one of the highest professional honors in the field, from the Academy of Management. She was appointed a Fellow of the Academy of Management in 2019. She was also awarded a National Science Foundation grant.

    View all posts
Click here for sharing